Name:
Location: Arizona

Saturday, September 03, 2005

I can't tell you how disappointed I am in Plato. Here I thought he was this great philosopher but in his Republic where he explores the idea of the ideal, utopian society, he totally puts down artists. Pretty much according to him, artists mainly poets, as he calls them, shouldn't be allowed in a civil and just society because they pollute the minds of the citizens. If you have them at all, they should be heavily censored and allowed to create only things that ennoble the gods and man. For example, fear of death is a bad thing so it is a taboo subject as is tragedy and or comedy. Boy, I bet the Athenian play-writes really liked him. Artists must never entertain anyone, just bore them to death. No fear there. It's a good thing no one ever really took him seriously because just about everything we know about ancient Greek culture is through the arts. Imagine, all we would have left is Plato and a totally wrong view of what they were like. He even thought Homer's Iliad should be censored because, (1) He made Zeus look petty and belligerent(which he was) and (2) He made the hero Achilles look non- heroic and whinny. Gods and heros must always look good because whatever you read you will become. I think he gives artists way too much credit.

Another thing that bugs me is that he thought that artists spoke the lowest level of the language. Excuse me! Artists speak the highest form of the language. Good grief. Imagine being married to this guy. Okay, one good thing he did was say that women should be educated the same as men. In that system of no beautiful or inspiring things to read or see, who would would care if they got educated. Ignorance is bliss, in this case anyway. How ironic, we finally find a guy who wants to give us equal rights and this is what we get.

7 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

4:30 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

4:31 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Will ThinkSecret Be Right Again?
ThinkSecret is not taking it easy. They are now reporting with detail that Apple will debut 70 and 140-song iPod phones and, later this month, iPod Mini/Shuffle revs.
My affiliate site:email account

5:44 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Blogs' profile in races grows
Web logs receiving more attention in Va. campaign season Sep 4, 2005 When Chadwick S. Dotson began his blog Commonwealth Conservative, he didn't know whether it would last for a week or a month.
Awesome Blog! I added you to my bookmarks. Feel free to check out this cool hip hop and rap site/blog, my boys run it!

5:44 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I still think Plato was brilliant. If by poetry, we read art--regular and, dare I say it, for the masses, then much of TV and film is about the basest of emotions and the most base of actions are depicted. If it is true that we are powerfully influenced by art, then this low art has a strong effect on society. That is what Plato was talking about. I don't know how anyone could disagree that art, unrestrained, often turns into that art that tweaks the emotions and the passions and does little to encourage logic or reason.

5:57 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

In one of the several versions of the ten commandments, doesn't it say "thou shalt not make graven images of ANY LIVING THING"? I guess that would include artists painting animals and people.
Geode

9:17 AM  
Blogger Anne Coe said...

To Geode, If we did or didn't do eveything we are told to door not do in the Bible we would be slaughtering oxen, keeping slaves, etc. etc. Anyway does graven here mean carved as in idols. I think it was all about hating the Babalonians and coveting (another sin) their wealth and successful imprisonment of the Isrealits. Afterall they were Pagan Goddess worshipers.

6:50 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home